Breathing room for Design

Sharbani Dhar at Product 2020

Design

Transcript
Accessible Slides

(upbeat music) - Hello everyone, before we get started with our presentation, let me just tell you a small story about Gina. Gina is the quintessential community activist, and she's my friend who wants to do her bit in everything. Come the pandemic she started to sew, and sew she did about 30 odd face masks as prescribed by the Australian Government Health website. And these masks were distributed to friends and neighbours. Then came her first trip to the supermarket with the mask on, and she did a complete product recall from all the 25 people that she had distributed the mask to.

The problem, no breathing room.

The masks stuck to her face and rubbed her lipstick off. So, after some trials, she came up with this. She's very happy with the outcome now as a lipstick stays safe and undisturbed.

Funnily enough, that is exactly what design teams in an enterprise face every day. In an urgency to hit the market, we often go the prescribed way without having the time or room to question it. However, we don't have the luxury of Gina to pivot and put out a new product the very next day. In summary, there's no breathing room for design to conceive and execute a delightful solution. Good morning everyone, I'm Sharbani Dhar, design director at Australia Post, an enterprise that has been the backbone of Australia for over 200 years, and.

- My name is Michelle O'Reilly, I'm the UX design leader Australia Post.

- Lovely to meet you all.

Today, we are here to take you through a case study on how we've created breathing room for design within our enterprise.

It's been a journey of trial and error, one, we are continuously looking to improve, these are some of our learnings for those of you who are facing similar challenges.

But first, a few facts about us.

We are over 210 years old, so yes, our first Postmaster General Isaac Nichols was in fact a convict, transported to New South Wales for stealing. Nichols was responsible for collecting the mail from newly arrived ships and distributing it to the colonies.

From the first post office in George Street in Sydney, we are now about 4300 post offices, spread across over 7.5 million square miles. Our post offices are the lifeblood of rural Australia, they're a key enabler of e-commerce, and from small businesses to large enterprises, our customer is everybody.

From the tech-savvy millennial in Melbourne to the lady knitting baby jumpers in cable Cora, where the nearest town is 700 kilometres away. A continual insult we often hear from people in our research over the years is that when banks close, they're not so fast.

But when post offices close in a rural town, people get very worried for if they don't have a post office, they feel that they don't consider themselves a town anymore.

That is the level of trust and responsibility Australia Post shoulders. Last year, we sent about 3.3 billion items across 12.1 million addresses in Australia and 214 countries across the world.

With the onset of COVID, our volumes have increased to triple than what we normally experience during peak times. It takes a lot to run a network and business of this size and making change is hard.

Believe me, there are some days when we feel as if we are working with technology from Mr Isaak Nichols himself. Having a large footprint means we have multiple operational dependencies and multiple operational complexities.

And this has become more obvious than ever before, during the pandemic.

- As the digital team at Australia Post, we are the facilitators for experiences.

It's our job to connect customers without them having to come physically to us and allow them to easily search service online. Most importantly, we are the key channel of communication in emergencies, bush fires, floods and the pandemic. The digital team is more than 500 people working across 20 engineering teams that are spread across four to five major programmes of work in the enterprise. For delivery, we follow the Scaled Agile Framework for enterprise or more commonly known as SAFe. SAFe is a framework that allows complex enterprises to adopt agile methodologies within our development teams. So that they can function in a lean manner where they can be nimble, agile and better able to react to market demands. In order for this to work, the whole digital team plans together every quarter.

We check in every six weeks to reassess the progress and planning, and we adapt to any changes.

Each team plans for their work, for every milestone that needs to be delivered for the next three months.

We then map the dependencies with other teams to ensure whether are teams with dependencies, they aren't operating in silos, but are communicating and planning together. However, SAFe is a self-aware development methodology. It has been a constant trial and error to mould and shape this process to ensure these experienced teams' needs are also accounted for. Australia Post is a really large enterprise with customers of various digital aptitudes across the country with legacy tech and old school stakeholders, this has been a very interesting challenge. It's not only how do we build the software, but how do we design that software in a way that's simple, useful, and delightful for our customers.

So what's that sweet spot? That allows for thinking time yet enables quick delivery? That is inclusive and enables collaboration with engineering and cross channel product partners? That enables the right tools and methodology for a problem? What's that sweet spot that allows breathing room, to create delightful experiences for our customers and the light's designed to inform strategy? - We tried a multitude of experiments to search for our perfect sweet spot, from working few sprints ahead to working just in time for the devs, to design sprinting to be better prepared.

And guide them to a few others in, from you know, our playbooks.

This is when we decided to experiment for dual track. This is where discovery and delivery run parallel to each other without a time dependency on each other. While experience continues its discovery towards an evolving vision that teams can use as a beacon, delivery becomes the incremental realisation of that vision.

As part of discovery track, we kick off end-to-end research and design activities that could ideally be at least a quarter to six weeks in advance before delivery kicks off.

Once we start to uncover the insights, the delivery teams can then start to pick them up as opportunities for quick wins.

As the research gets more and more mature and findings get media delivery can then start to plan for bigger pieces of work.

Why this works? Removing time dependency between experience research and delivery, allowed further breathing room to think, unpack and invite cross channel collaboration.

Continuous slicing of learnings from research into smaller pieces of delivery, allowed delivery teams to work towards meaningful and viable outcomes.

Identifying quick wins also allowed for quick, not so expensive fails, while making time for research on more complex problems.

How this works? How does this really work? Let's look at our double diamond for a bit to see how it fits into dual track.

The first half of the diamond, learn is when the discovery track kicks off and the create half is where the delivery track kicks off. Learn is when we try to spend as much time as we can, understanding the problem, learning as much as we can about it, so that then we can begin to create. Now, when I say discovery track, I don't mean that this is an activity that is solely owned by experience. In the same way delivery track is not solely owned by the tech.

So for this to work, it is of utmost importance to identify the right balance of people for driving the right parts.

The participants of discovery track are therefore the product managers from viability, the software architect from tech and the design directors from design driving, the research and vision setting.

The participants for delivery, are business analysts from viability, the developers from tech and designers from design driving the delivery for an optimization.

Now this is important, while these two tracks run parallel to each other, the producers, iteration managers and the leads become the connectors of the two tracks. Having roles that work upstream rules the flow downstream with kind of does in the process who ensure that there's a constant dialogue happening between the two, facilitates the space and breathing room to focus on the right parts of the process at the right time. From day one, we also operated on showing full transparency of our processes and methods.

The team were unclear around UX processes, and we took every opportunity possible to educate and answer any questions they had.

We instigated a weekly share back that was an open forum for 30 minutes.

We would share back progress and take anyone that is interested on the journey, explaining the decisions we were making.

It was an open forum for collaboration, product owners, security experts, engineers, architects, business stakeholders, just about anybody could come and keep across the project as often as they wished. - Our first experiment with this new delivery approach was the redesign for mail redirection, Mail redirection is a service that allows you to have your mail redirected from one address to a new one. And it's most commonly used by people when they move to a new home.

Mail redirection is one of our most expensive services that we provide.

Unfortunately, that was the drive's the maximum calls in customer complaints.

When we kicked off the discovery truck, we were off with an unclear problem and an unclear solution. We knew that customers are complaining.

But that wasn't the problem, that was the symptom. By starting the discovery track it allowed us to separate the problems from the symptoms. To see what's really impacting our customers and our staff. At the same time, we found that 30,000 customers were forced to call us, as they were unable to verify their identity online owing to special ID requirements.

This allowed us to identify an opportunity we could add towards delivery backlog.

We could open up servicing 85% of concession customers online.

This was a big win for our concession customers because they have high rates of disabilities and mobility issues.

And the cost of travelling to a post office for them can add significant stress to their budget. This has been especially helpful to customers during COVID, as we are allowing them more flexibility for them to apply to their preferred channel of choice. Through continuous research throughout the project we uncovered lots of issues.

However, the biggest issue was that we keep getting in our own way.

What I mean by that is, that over time people spotted opportunities to piggyback on the traffic of this product.

Over the years, multiple upsells slip their way into the flow on a road to the experience. During testing customers would get so distracted by all of these upsells that they would forget the original intent of the task they were trying to complete.

The solution was simple, move upsells outside the flow to increase overall conversion rates.

Most importantly, based on our research and analysis we were able to set up the right measures of success which became our criteria to continue optimization post delivery.

We use data to inform decisions and decide when features were suitable to be released into production. This helped us get big changes across the line and build trust with our stakeholders.

The project was a success, it came in ahead of schedule and budget, we met and exceeded all expectations, some of which such as the overall conversion for mail redirection significantly.

So what does this mean? Having the breathing room to collaborate and proactively work through dual track, has allowed us to build partnerships instead of receiving a list of requirements, establish a continuous culture of measure and learning, prove the value of design and experience to the point that now design informs strategy. - So all these trials or all these experiments what do they really mean for you who are watching? Creating breathing room starts with creating transparency, a brick and mortar enterprise, which has multiple operations trying to work together, will not always have a prescribed process.

But whatever process you choose needs to start with creating transparency about it for all the players involved.

We as design can sit in a corner and complain that we don't get hurt.

In the beginning, we were asking for a seat at the table without really offering a chair at our own. Getting out of that mindset and having partnerships enabled us to build and try different methods. A framework is good, as long as you allow a bit of push and pull into it.

To create the breathing room means not being a fundamentalist in agile or design thinking, or even design sprints or you know, service blueprinting. But identifying what works best for the opportunity. Don't drink the Kool-Aid just because the cult leader says. No, the different roles in an organisation work better at different instances of the problem solving process. Identify them, utilise them, but also bridge them. So that one role in one part of the process is not disconnected from the other.

Agree early on, regarding what metrics you want to deliver on.

Validate their relevance as part of your research and implement and monitor them as part of your delivery. Finally do not forget, it's never over.

It's a continuous process of improvement.

Thank you.

(upbeat music)

Breathing room for Design

Sharbani Dhar, Director–Design Operations, Michelle O’Reilly, Lead product designer, Australia Post

Close-up photograph of a woman wearing a blue, hospital style face mask.

Replay of prior slide with cartoon graphic overlaid of a mask with a heart attached

Image of a woman wearing a different style of handmade mask with more coverage and fitting more loosely. Text box is overlaid on the image reading: Adopt the prescribed way in an urgency to hit the market.

Breathing room for design

Red background the colour of the Australia Post logo, which appears at the bottom of the slide.

Image of an Australia Post mail truck driving in outback Australia. A text box is overlaid on the image with a quote from Diana Elliot, an ABC journalist: Post offices fulfill a social service as well as a commercial one. They stand stoically in townships decimated by floors, plagues, and financial ruin, like chimneys rising from the ashes of homes destroyed by fire.

Image of the first Postmaster General in Australia holding a handwritten sign advertizing post office location and hours.

Image of a modern post box in a country town near an old weatherboard post office. A text banner overlaid on the image reads: With great trust comes great responsibility.

Image of a central mail processing and distribution centre with large pieces of machinery for sorting mail. A text banner overlaid on the image reads: 210 years legacy. Multiple complexities.

Image of a hand holding a smartphone open to a scanner app screen and scanning a barcode on the wall of the post office. A text banner overlaid on the image is headed: Where does digital fit in? Sub bullets read: Facilitator. Connector. Communicator.

Image of an engineering team in an office. Many have their hands raised. A text banner overlaid on the image is headed: The Digital Team. Sub bullets read: Scaled Agile Framework for Enterprise. For enterprises to achieve business agility.

Illustration of stick figure style people in front of a whiteboard covered in post-its arranged into flow and cycle charts. A graph is overlaid on the board, with X-axis reading three months and Y-axis reading: 6 week check ins. A text box beside the illustration is headed: SAFe working. Sub bullets read: Plan every three months. Six week check ins. Map dependencies.

Photographic image that repeats the illustration from the prior slide with an employee in front of a whiteboard covered in post-it maps. A text box under the photograph is headed: The challenge for experience. Sub bullets read: building software for a large brick and mortar enterprise.

Searching for the sweet spot...

Red background the colour of the Australia Post logo.

Illustration of a stick figure person with a large thought bubble. Inside the bubble, text reads: What's the sweet spot? Numbered list reads: 1)That allows for thinking time yet enables quick delivery. 2)That is inclusive and enables collaboration. 3)That enables the right tools for a problem.

Text banner reading: Going 'Dual Track'. Underneath the banner, icon of a magnifying glass and a right point arrow captioned: Discovery track. The arrow points to an icon of a mountain captioned: Towards and evolving vision.

A secondary arrow appears pointing toward the mountain icon captioned: Delivery track. The arrow has several markers along its trajectory. Text beside this arrow reads: Incremental realization of the vision.

Zoomed in image of the Discovery and Delivery track sections with curved red arrows pointing downward from discovery to delivery.

The markers on the zoomed in delivery track image change from white to red and increase on size scale as the red arrows reach them at farther points on the axis.

Image of an entire office wall dotted with post-it notes of various colours representing flow and cycle charts. A text box overlaid on the image is titled: Why this works. Sub bullets read: Removes time dependency. Meaningful outcomes. Failures are not costly.

Graphic representation of the double diamond approach. A diamond shape labelled: learn is accompanied by the text: finding the right problem. The discovery track arrow is above the diamond.

A second diamond appears next to the first and is labelled: create. It is accompanied by the text: Finding the right solution. The delivery track arrow is below the diamond.

A diamond shape underneath the discovery track arrow features stick figure icons inside labelled project manager, design director, and architect.

A second diamond appears next to the first, above the delivery track arrow. Stick figure icons inside are labeled Business Analyst, Developer, and designer. These figures face the figures in the discovery track diamond.

Between the diamonds, a row of stick figure icons appears, labeled: Experience leads, iteration managers, and producers.

On the left of the slide, a red arrow pointing up is labeled: Informing strategy. Beside it are the project manager, architect, and design director icons. On the right of the slide, a red arrow pointing downward is labeled: Crafting delivery. Beside is are the business analyst, developer, and designer icons.

Between the two teams, a third team appears labeled: Connecting both. The experience leads, iteration managers, and producer icons are in this group. Red arrows point from them to the two teams on either side.

Illustration of a round table with stick figure icons sitting around it whilst on stick figure presents on a board labeled: Findings today, with various graphics and information.

Image of an Australia Post van driving through a city street. A graphic of a stick figure standing outside a house is overlaid on the image.

A text box titled: Discovery track - learn appears over the image. Sub-text in the box reads: Uplifting our mail redirection service.

The Discovery track text box from the last slide is repeated here. Beside, an illustration of a stick figure scratching their head standing next to a cardboard box labeled: Unclear problem. Unclear Solution. A large question mark symbol is inside the box.

Image of an Australia Post storefront with blurred images of customers. A self-serve kiosk is visible inside the storefront. A text box is overlaid on the image and is titled: Clarity on the problem. Sub bullets read: We had a large percentage of customers being forced in store where mobility and cost of transport is a large pain point. Allowing these customers to self serve would also drive revenue for the business.

Illustration of a stick figure appearing stressed. Thought bubbles of exclamations and information surround the figure. A text box beside the illustration reads: Clarity on the problem.

Bullet under Clarity on the problem read: Multiple upsells that were distracting for users.

Illustration of stick figures looking at a chart with plot point icons. A text box beside this reads: Delivery Track - create: Sub- bullets read: Clear problem, clear solution. Continuing the culture of learning. Clear measures of success as part of delivery.

Illustration of stick figures high-fiving. A text box underneath reads: Proving the Value. Ahead of schedule and on budget. Met and exceeded objectives.

Text box reads: So far...bullets read: partnerships instead of requirements. measuring and learning towards an evolving vision. Prove value of design where now design informs strategy. Above the text box are illustrations of stick figures holding hands, a growth graph with an exclamation point beside it, and a lightbulb with a heart icon inside.

So... what does this all mean for you?

Creating breathing room starts with creating transparency.

Illustration of a stick figure emoji holding up stacks of bars. A text box underneath reads: Allow for a bit of push and pull.

Illustration of three stick figure emojis with bidirectional arrows between them. Text box reads: Have an operating model to support the business.

Slider dissolves into an illustration of a satellite. Text box reads: Metrics to prove the work - agreed as part of discovery, implemented as part of delivery.